Shenzhen RFQ And BOM Specification Comparison For Project Buyers

SZ
CLUSTER 01
P5
RFQ DESKCinosourcing / Cluster Atlas
RFQ And BOM: Comparing What Can Be Compared
RFQ DESK / BOM tree and comparison bands  /  buyer-side sourcing note  /  P5
Cluster desk / talk to Andrew
info@cinosourcing.com  |  +86 186 7676 3055
STAGE 01
BRIEF
STAGE 02
MAP
STAGE 03
VERIFY
STAGE 04
FREEZE
STAGE 05
LOAD
One-line answer

A Shenzhen RFQ and BOM specification comparison is only useful when two suppliers are pricing the same product. In practice one quotation assumes a different component maker, another quietly excludes testing, and a third bundles tooling into a unit price that looks lower. The buyer then compares numbers that describe three different objects. We work on the buyer side as a procurement desk: we freeze one specification revision, send the same field set to every candidate, and normalise the answers into a matrix before a deposit is discussed. This is the opening stage of custom manufacturing, repeat stock and project procurement. We do not manufacture, do not issue certificates and give no market-entry conclusions; destination requirements stay with the importer and qualified advisers.

01

Families the BOM has to describe

A bill of materials is not one flat list. Purchased parts, made-to-drawing parts and service or packing lines each need different fields, and each produces a different verification record later.

Families and the records each one pulls
Purchased components
Standard parts quoted by maker and part number with approved alternatives.
Part numberApproved makerSubstitution ruleLot traceability
Made-to-drawing parts
Machined, moulded or stamped items defined by a drawing revision and tolerance.
Drawing revisionMaterialFinishFirst article
Programme lines
Tooling, testing, firmware, packing and freight inputs that are commercial assumptions rather than parts.
Tooling ownershipTest scopeArtwork versionCarton data
02

Comparison matrix for two supplier answers

The matrix below is the normalised view we build before showing a recommendation. Every cell is an assumption the supplier must confirm, not a number we invent. The RFQ specification carries the same fields.

RFQ comparison / one revision
Field Supplier A Supplier B Buyer note
Component makers Stated or left open Stated or left open An open cell is not a comparable quotation
Tooling and setup Separate line or bundled Separate line or bundled Ownership and custody must be written
Testing scope Which checks are included Which checks are included Unpriced testing is not free testing
Packing Carton, marks and language Carton, marks and language Compare against the approved artwork
Change rules How a revision is approved How a revision is approved One owner for both suppliers
03

Bands of assumption that change a quotation

Four bands account for most apparent price differences. Separating them turns a confusing pair of offers into a readable list of decisions, and keeps landed cost discussions grounded in the same specification.

Parts
Approved makers, part numbers and alternatives.
A substitution can move both cost and document coverage without changing the photograph.
Process
In-house steps, subcontracted steps and test limits.
A different process route is a different product, not a cheaper version of the same one.
Tooling
Mould, fixture, programme, ownership and custody.
Bundled tooling hides who owns the tool after the first run.
Logistics
Packing, carton data, consolidation and document scope.
Two quotations with different freight assumptions cannot be compared line by line.
04

Drawers in the RFQ file

The request for quotation is a controlled document with an owner. The drawers below are the ones we hold so a later change can be traced to the version that was quoted.

Open one drawer per destination market
01
Category schedule
Models or drawings, quantity tiers, destination markets and packing requirements.
Buyer supplies
02
Controlled specification
Material, components, finish, artwork and packing under one revision via the specification sheet.
Buyer approves
03
Supplier answers
Itemised assumptions from each candidate, not a single bundled figure.
Desk normalises
04
Verification evidence
Entity, address and step list from factory verification.
Verification desk
05
Decision note
Which version was approved, by whom, and which shipments it applies to.
Buyer + desk
05

A ladder from brief to approved comparison

Each rung produces the input for the next. The discipline is to avoid asking for a price before the product is defined, and to avoid approving a sample before the assumptions are written.

01
Write the brief
Models or drawings, quantity tiers, destination markets and intended use.
02
Freeze the specification
One revision covering parts, materials, finish, firmware, artwork and packing.
03
Send the same field set
Every candidate receives the same RFQ document and the same question list.
04
Normalise the answers
Itemise assumptions and mark open cells before comparing commercial terms.
05
Verify the shortlist
Confirm entity, address and step list for the candidates still in scope.
06
Approve a sample
Use written approval gates and record the revision.
06

Checks before the comparison becomes an order

Before a purchase order is issued, the approved revision should be visible in every downstream document. The list below is what we confirm with first-article and inspection records where relevant.

Revision on the order
The purchase order cites the same specification revision as the comparison.
Assumptions closed
Open cells in the comparison matrix are answered in writing.
Tooling terms
Ownership, custody and return conditions are recorded.
Change owner
One person can approve and reissue a revision.
Inspection reference
The protocol cites the approved specification and the shipment number.
Questions international distributors actually ask
Why do two quotations look so different?

Usually because the parts, process route, tooling or logistics assumptions differ. Normalise them before comparing commercial terms.

Can a supplier write its own specification?

It may contribute technical input, but the buyer must approve a single controlled document.

Is a sample enough to close an RFQ?

No. The written specification, itemised assumptions and change rules still need approval.

Who owns tooling after the first run?

That must be written into the agreement before a deposit, not assumed from the unit price.

Do you quote prices in this note?

No. This note describes how to make supplier quotations comparable; commercial terms are agreed per order.

What should I send first?

A category list with models or drawings, quantity tiers, destination markets and packing requirements.

Scope note / commercial boundaries

This is a commercial sourcing note, not legal, customs or regulatory advice. We work on the buyer side as a sourcing and freight partner based in Shenzhen; we are not a factory, a certification body or a licensed customs broker, and we do not issue certificates or give market-entry conclusions. Product classification, destination requirements, labelling, language, tariff treatment and duties must be confirmed by the importer with qualified advisers and a licensed broker in each destination market. Requirements differ between markets and change over time; nothing here is specific to one country.

WhatsApp +86 186 7676 3055  |  info@cinosourcing.com  |  www.cinosourcing.com

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *