PCBA Inspection and Testing: What a Factory Must Prove

DESK NOTE 02 / EVIDENCE OF QUALITY
Every factory says it inspects. The useful question is what it inspects, with which equipment, at which process stage, and what record you receive.
PCBA inspection test planSPI AOI X-Ray AXIIPC-A-610 Class 2/3FAI first articleICT FCT burn-in8D reportlot traceability

A board can look perfect under a bench light and still fail in the field six months later. Solder voids under a BGA, a marginally wet joint, a wrong-value passive part or a latent moisture defect are not visible in a final visual check. This page is a buyer-side map of the inspection and test stack, and of the documents that should travel with a PCBA shipment from China.

We are a sourcing, QC and freight partner, not a PCB fabricator, an electronics design house, a test laboratory or a certification body. We coordinate qualified factories, request and check their documents, arrange inspection and consolidate the shipment. Design decisions and compliance determinations stay with your engineer, the importer and the authority having jurisdiction.

01

Why a visual check is not a test plan

Visual inspection answers one question: does the assembly look acceptable? It does not answer whether the paste volume was correct, whether a hidden joint formed properly, whether every component value matches the BOM, or whether the board performs its function under load. Those require different checks at different points in the process, and each one catches a different class of defect.

The practical consequence is that an inspection claim on a quotation is not a specification. Ask for the list of checkpoints, the equipment used at each one, the sampling rule, the acceptance standard and the record that will be supplied. A factory with a disciplined process can usually answer all four without hesitation.

02

The inspection stack from paste to packed unit

STAGE 01
IQC and paste
Incoming component checks, MSL handling and storage, then 3D solder paste inspection before placement.
→
STAGE 02
Placement and reflow
First article confirmation, pre-reflow AOI where used, controlled reflow profile with recorded curve.
→
STAGE 03
Post-reflow
AOI for missing, shifted or reversed parts and solder defects; X-ray or AXI for BGA, QFN and LGA joints.
→
STAGE 04
Electrical
ICT or flying probe for opens, shorts and values; FCT against the agreed functional specification.
→
STAGE 05
Reliability and pack
Burn-in, thermal cycling or environmental screening where required, then final QA and ESD-safe packing.
→

Not every project needs every stage. A simple two-layer board for a consumer accessory and a Class 3 industrial controller should not carry the same test scope. The point is to choose deliberately and write the chosen scope into the order, rather than discover after a failure that a stage was never performed.

03

What each test actually detects

REQUIREMENT
SPI
WHAT TO REQUEST
Paste volume, height, area and offset on every pad before components are placed.
WHO CONFIRMS
Process engineer reviews SPC data; buyer asks for the report format.
REQUIREMENT
AOI
WHAT TO REQUEST
Missing, wrong, reversed or skewed parts, solder bridges, insufficient solder and tombstoning after reflow.
WHO CONFIRMS
Factory supplies AOI coverage and defect logs; buyer requests summary records.
REQUIREMENT
X-ray / AXI
WHAT TO REQUEST
Hidden joints under BGA, QFN, LGA and bottom-terminated packages; voids, head-in-pillow and bridging.
WHO CONFIRMS
Factory provides sample images and the void acceptance rule agreed in the RFQ.
REQUIREMENT
ICT / flying probe
WHAT TO REQUEST
Opens, shorts, wrong component values and orientation against the netlist.
WHO CONFIRMS
Test engineer confirms coverage; buyer asks which nets are untested.
REQUIREMENT
FCT
WHAT TO REQUEST
Real behaviour under power against a written test specification, including I/O, communications and firmware version.
WHO CONFIRMS
Buyer approves the test specification; factory supplies per-unit or batch logs.
REQUIREMENT
Burn-in / thermal
WHAT TO REQUEST
Early-life failures, thermal stress and behaviour across temperature extremes where the application requires it.
WHO CONFIRMS
Buyer and engineer set duration, conditions and pass criteria.

Ask which nets and which joints are not covered. A test plan with a coverage gap is fine if the gap is known and accepted; it is a problem when the gap is discovered after a field return.

04

IPC-A-610 classes and the workmanship baseline

IPC-A-610 is the assembly acceptability standard most factories reference, and its classes are a decision the buyer makes. Class 2 covers general service products where extended life and uninterrupted service are not critical. Class 3 applies to high-reliability products where continued performance is essential and downtime cannot be tolerated. Class 1 is for general consumer products. IPC-A-600 covers bare board acceptability, J-STD-001 the soldering process, and IPC-7711/7721 rework and repair.

NAME THE CLASS IN THE PURCHASE ORDER
Stating a class in a capabilities brochure is not the same as building to it. Put the class in the RFQ and the purchase order, ask whether daily production runs to that class as standard, and request the inspection criteria the operator uses. For high-reliability sectors, ask for the supporting workmanship evidence rather than a logo on a quotation.

Related process controls belong in the same conversation: ANSI/ESD S20.20 for electrostatic discharge, J-STD-033 for moisture-sensitive device handling, and a documented rework procedure that prevents uncalibrated manual touch-up on multilayer boards. These are the details that separate a controlled line from a bench operation.

05

First article, traceability and the records that travel

A first article inspection answers whether the first units produced under the real production process conform to the released specification. It is a gate, not a final inspection. Agree what happens if the first article fails, who signs the release and whether a golden sample is retained by both sides.

First article report with measurements, polarity and orientation checks against the approved file revision.
Serial or lot traceability linking material batches, placement programme, reflow profile, operator and test data.
Test logs per unit or per batch, X-ray images for area-array packages, and a signed final QA record.
Certificate of conformance, packing list and photos of packing, labelling and container loading.
A defined retention period for records so a field issue can be investigated months later.

Our first article inspection guide covers that gate in detail, and our pre-shipment inspection service explains dimensional checks, label review, packing inspection and photo records before the balance payment. The medical device document pack checklist shows the same discipline at a higher documentation level.

06

Defects, rework and the corrective response

A quality system is judged by what happens when something goes wrong. Ask how a defect is contained, how suspect stock is segregated, whether rework follows a documented procedure, and when a corrective action report is issued. The common format is an 8D report: team, problem description, containment, root cause, corrective action, verification, prevention and closure.

Containment
Stop the affected lot, identify the affected serials and quarantine stock before further shipment.
Root cause
Distinguish a design issue, a material issue, a process parameter drift and an operator error.
Verification
Confirm the corrective action on a new build and record the evidence, not just the intention.
Commercial
Agree in writing how rework, replacement, freight and warranty claims are handled across borders.

Ask for the rule before there is a claim. A supplier that can describe its corrective process calmly is usually one that has used it.

07

Writing the test plan into the RFQ

The test scope should be a named line in the quotation, not an implied extra. List the required checkpoints, the acceptance class, the coverage expectation, the records to be supplied and the person who signs the release. Then make sure the inspection records refer to the same file revision as the purchase order.

Included as standard
State which inspection stages are in the quoted price and which are optional additions.
Fixture and programming
State who supplies and owns the test fixture, stencil, programme and firmware file.
Records
Name the reports, images, logs and certificates delivered with the shipment and their format.
Acceptance
Name the workmanship class, the pass criteria for FCT and the void or coverage limits where relevant.
Change control
State what happens if the design, a component or the test specification changes after release.

We do not run these tests or issue the reports. We request them from the factory, check that they correspond to the quoted build and revision, flag gaps before the order is released, arrange third-party or pre-shipment inspection where the buyer wants it, and keep the checked file with the shipment. Our supplier verification process describes how the factory behind the documents is checked.

Our quoted price already includes our margin. There is no separate sourcing fee or commission added on top, and we do not set a strict MOQ of our own. Factory minimums vary by specification and are confirmed in writing before any deposit.

Ask for the test scope before you ask for the price

Send your BOM, board construction and destination market. We return a written list of the inspection stages and records we will request, and flag any checkpoint the shortlisted factory cannot evidence.

This page is general procurement guidance, not engineering design advice or a compliance determination. Standards, layer counts, tolerances and inspection methods named here are examples of what buyers ask a factory to confirm in writing; they are not a statement of our own production capacity. Final specifications, approvals and acceptance criteria must be set by the project engineer, the importer and the authority having jurisdiction for the destination market.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *